SAAarchitectsSAAarchitects

6 Tips for Choosing an Architect for a Historic Building Renovation

October 26, 2026
  • Share This Article
Balancing Tradition and Innovation

Whether it’s a 19th-century farmhouse, church, or community landmark, renovating an old building is a significant undertaking. Historic building renovation requires a deep understanding of what makes a building special, what can and should change, and how to preserve its original charm.

Choosing the right partner is crucial to your project’s success. An experienced architectural firm can help you navigate regulatory challenges, local approvals, preservation requirements, and potential tax-credit considerations while revitalizing historic buildings for modern needs and occupants.

So, how do you find the best firm for the job? Here are six tips to help make your search easier.

How to Choose an Architect for a Historic Renovation

  1. Compile a List of Potential Partners

First things first: confirm your building is registered as historic by checking the National Register of Historic Places, the country’s official list of historic buildings.

Then, make a list of architectural firms suitable for your project. Do a quick Google search using terms like “historic renovation architect” or “historic preservation architectural firm.”

You can also use resources like your State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO), local historical societies, or preservation organizations, all of which should be able to point you in the right direction.

  1. Key Selection Criteria

Once you’ve compiled your list, do your due diligence on each firm. Read online reviews, explore their portfolios of recent projects, and look for any specific certifications or expertise that would make them the ideal partner for handling the scope and scale of your project.

For instance, if you want to convert an abandoned factory into a mixed-use center, look for a firm with experience in both residential and commercial design.

You should also consider regulatory experience and material sensitivity. Make sure the firm knows how to navigate historic district guidelines and approval processes, and whether they prioritize sustainable practices, like using eco-friendly, energy-efficient materials.

  1. Do They Specialize in Restoration, Preservation, or Both?

When choosing an architect, it’s important to understand the difference between historic restoration, preservation, and renovation. Historic preservation is the practice of identifying, protecting, and maintaining old structures, often those with cultural, historical, or architectural significance.

Historic restoration returns a building to its exact condition and appearance during a specific period in history. Renovation, or adaptive reuse, by contrast, updates, repairs, and modernizes historic structures so they’re safe and functional for contemporary use.

Often, historic preservation and renovation go hand in hand, so find a firm that specializes in both.

  1. Research and Documentation

You may be entitled to grants and financial incentives for renovating a historic building. An experienced historic preservation firm can help you better navigate this process, including:

  • Conducting a feasibility study
  • Researching local libraries and archives for relevant information on the structure
  • Working with all local, state, and federal agencies regarding certifications, qualifications, and grants that can apply to your project

With over 30 years of expertise, SAAarchitects’ historic preservation process covers all of this and more, ensuring the final results aren’t just beautiful and functional, but cost-effective.

  1. Local Approval Expertise

Historic buildings involve more stakeholders than a typical renovation. Depending on the property, you may need to work with local historic commissions, architectural review boards, zoning officials, building departments, state agencies, or federal preservation programs.

Make sure the firm you pick has experience with:

  • Navigating the approval process
  • Working with any and all agencies that might be involved in the project
  • Preparing the necessary submissions and documentations
  • Familiarity with historic district reviews

An architect who understands the regulatory landscape can help identify potential issues earlier in the process.

6. Project Challenges Unique to Historic Renovation

Renovating a historic structure comes with many challenges you may not face when building or updating newer buildings. Discuss these challenges with your architectural firm, so you know from the start if they can help you overcome them and keep your project on track.

Just a few of the hurdles you may encounter include:

  • Regulations and Permit Approvals: Historic preservation requirements are extremely intricate and lengthy, creating potential delays that can stall your timeline.
  • Custom Materials: Some historic buildings may need materials or architectural elements that aren’t readily available, causing recreation or procurement challenges.
  • Unforeseen Risks: Older buildings can have hidden hazards, including asbestos, lead paint, decay, structural damage, and foundation issues that may not become apparent until renovation begins. A feasibility study will uncover these risks and help keep your project on budget and on schedule.

Trust Your Historic Building Renovation to SAAarchitects

A historic building renovation is an opportunity to do more than repair an aging structure. Done properly, it can preserve architectural character, support a new purpose, and give an existing building another chapter in its story.

Finding an architect with the right renovation experience makes that process much more informed and manageable.

SAAarchitects approaches each project by understanding the existing building, evaluating its possibilities, and developing strategies that respect its history while preparing it for the future.

We recently restored a beloved bandstand in York, PA, into a community venue. Despite a limited budget and a deteriorated structure, we preserved the bandstand’s unique character while replacing damaged features with modern materials. 

The restoration met state and federal preservation standards and included ADA accessibility, energy-efficient lighting, electrical upgrades, improved storage access, and sustainable features. 

Explore our portfolio of other historic preservation projects to learn what we can do for you.

Designing Manufacturing Facilities as Quiet Good Neighbors
Previous

Designing Manufacturing Facilities as Quiet Good Neighbors

Beyond the Floor Plan: Commercial Architects in York, PA on Human
Next

Beyond the Floor Plan: Commercial Architects in York, PA on Human